The chip under the Spread tiles is the target, what the dots line layers up with. Click it to go from Selection to Comp to Key layer and round again. Right-click it to pick one from a menu.

The menu has the three targets and the Gap field. Click outside it to close it.

The target stays until you close the panel. Settings sets the one it starts with.

TargetThe dots line layers up with
SelectionThe outer edges of all the selected layers together. One layer goes to the comp.
CompThe comp’s edges and center.
Key layerThe first layer you selected. It never moves.

The target only changes what the dots do. Spread always works between the selected layers.

A key layer

Pick Key layer on the chip. Click the layer that should stay put first, then add the others to the selection, then click a dot.

The pad outlines the key layer in blue. Everything else lines up with it: centered on it with the center dot, or level with its top with the top middle dot.

If the key layer is the only one selected, Evensteven shows Select 2+.

Move layers as one block

Hold Cmd (Ctrl on Windows) when you click a dot. The selection moves as one block, so the layers keep their places relative to each other, gaps and all.

With Comp on the chip, Cmd-click the center dot to center a whole row in the frame.

With Selection on the chip, a Cmd-click lines the block up with the comp, since a block can’t line up with itself. With Key layer, the block lines up with the key layer.