A layer didn’t move
It’s locked or has an expression on Position, and the message says how many were skipped. Unlock the layer, or turn its Position expression off, and click again. Layers with no picture, such as audio, are left out without a count.
The layers line up, then the animation looks wrong
Evensteven measured the layers at the playhead. If a layer was still moving at that frame, it lined up mid-move. Undo, put the playhead where everything has landed, and click again. See Align animated layers.
The layers slide into line during the animation
The click was an Alt-click, which writes one key at the playhead instead of moving the whole animation. Undo and click without Alt.
A rotated layer lines up by a corner
That’s its visible edge. Evensteven lines layers up by what you see, so a rotated layer’s lowest or leftmost corner is its edge. A rotated layer’s box in the pad is the box around everything it shows.
Shapes with dashed or curved strokes line up a little off
After Effects measures a shape by its path’s handles, which can reach past the curve you see, and Evensteven uses that measurement. Align such shapes by their centers, or line them up by a layer with straight edges as the key layer.
A single layer jumped to the edge of the comp
With Selection on the chip, one layer lines up with the comp, because there’s nothing else to line up with. The same goes for a Cmd-click. Pick Key layer to line up with another layer.
Spread says Select 3+
Equal gaps need at least three layers, since two layers only have one gap. To set the gap between two layers, type it in Gap and Shift-click Spread.
The key layer moved, or the wrong layer stayed put
The key layer is the first one you selected. Deselect everything, click the layer that should stay put, then add the others.
Spread moved the key layer
Spread works between every selected layer and doesn’t use the target, so a key layer can move when you spread. While Key layer is on the chip, the dashed preview over a Spread tile leaves the key layer out, but the click still spreads it with the others.
A 3D layer lines up off to one side through the camera
3D layers line up by their X and Y in the comp’s world. Seen through a camera at an angle, perspective moves them on screen, so they can look out of line. Layers facing the camera square line up as you see them.
Evensteven shows Not done
After Effects couldn’t measure one of the layers, often because an expression somewhere on it has an error. Nothing was changed. Fix the error and click again.
Evensteven shows No comp or No selection
Open the comp, select the layers, and click again.